- 文献要素
-
摘要:公共工程建设为我国的经济和社会发展提供了强有力的基础,但实践中仍存在大量工程失控,不可持续等价值实现失败的问题,过往研究也很少关注公共工程价值实现问题。本文界定价值内涵,分析价值实现内涵,指出公共工程价值实现应关注铁三角(工期、成本和质量)之外的价值。然后分析已有价值实现框架,并指出已有价值框架适用于公共工程的局限性,以期为针对公共工程价值实现框架的构建提供参考。
关键词:公共工程;价值实现;铁三角;项目管理
Abstract:Public projects provide a strong foundation for the economic and social development in China. However,management issues,such as runaway and unsustainable projects,are common in practice,eroding project value creation. Prior researches have paid little attention to the value creation of public projects. This paper elaborates the concept of value and value realization,points out that value creation of public projects should go beyond the iron triangle. Then,analyzes the existing frameworks of value realization to identify the limitations of their application on public projects,in order to provide reference to value creation framework of public projects.
Keywords:public project;value realization;iron triangle;project management
参考文献
[1] 赵岩.工程哲学的实践运用问题研究[D].新乡:河南师范大学,2009.
[2] Bell,K. The strategic management of projects to enhance value for money for BAA PLC[D]. Edinburgh,Heriot Watt University,1994.
[3] 国家发展改革委员会,建设部.项目经济评价方法与参数[M].北京:中国计划出版社,2006.
[4] Zhao Y. Lagging social impact assessment for public project management in China:Inappropriate method or lack of interest[A]. Fifth International Conference on Business Intelligence and Financial Engineering,2012.
[5] Haddadi A,Johansen A,Andersen B. A conceptual framework to enhance value creation in construction[J]. Project management,2016.
[6] Samset K. Project evaluation:Making investments succeed[M]. Trondheim:Tapir Academic Press,2003.
[7] Pinto MB,Pinto KB. Determinants of cross-functional cooperation in the project implementation process[J]. Project Management Journal,1991(22):13-20.
[8] Shenhar AJ,Levy O,Dvir D. Mapping dimensions of projects success[J]. Project Management Journal,1997(2):5-13.
[9] Dvir D,Lechler T. Plans are nothing,changing plans is everything:The impact of changes on project success[J]. Res. Policy,2004(33):1-15.
[10] Bryde DJ,Robinson L. Client versus contractor perspectives on project success criteria[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2005(23):622-629.
[11] Kim BC,Reinschmidt KF. Combination of project cost forecasts in earned value management[J]. Journal of Construction Engineering Management,2011,137:958-966.
[12] Sato CEY,Jr MDFC. Chagas. When do megaprojects start and finish? Redefining project lead time for megaproject success[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2014(7):624-637.
[13] Berssaneti FT,Carvalho MM. Identification of variables that impact project success in Brazilian companies[J]. International journal of Project Management,2014(7):638-649.
[14] Joslin R,Müller R. Relationships between a project management methodology and project success in different project governance contexts[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2015(6):377-1392.
[15] Jiang W,Lu Y,Le Y. Trust and project success:A twofold perspective between owners and contractors[J]. Journal of Management Engineering,2016(32):1-16.
[16] Carvalho MM,Rabechini R. Can project sustainability management impact project success? An empirical study applying a contingent approach[J]. International journal of Project Management,2017,355:1120-1132.
[17] Luo L,He Q,Xie J et al. Investigating the relationship between project complexity and success in complex construction projects[J]. Journal of Management Engineering,2017(33).
[18] Carvalho MM,Patah LL,Bido D. Project management and its effects on project success:cross-country and cross-industry comparisons[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2015(33):1509-1522.
[19] Fahri J,Biesenthal C,Pollack J et al. Understanding megaproject success beyond the project close- out stage[J]. Construction Economic Building,2015(15):48-58.
[20] Koskela L,Glenn B. Should project management be based on theories of economics or production?[J]. Building Research & Information,2006(2):154-163.
[21] Zwikael O,Smyrk J. A general framework for gauging the performance of initiatives to enhance organizational value[J]. British Journal of Management,2012(S1):6-22.
[22] Baccarini D. The logical framework method for defining project success[J].Project Management Journal,1999(4):25-32.
[23] Shenhar AJ,Levy O,Dvir D. Mapping dimensions of projects success[J].Project Management Journal,1997(2):5-13.
[24] Atkinson R. Project management:Cost,time and quality,two best guesses and a phenomenon,it’s time to accept other success criteria[J]. International Journal of Project Management,1999(6):337-342.
[25] 成虎.工程全寿命期管理[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2011.
建筑经济,2018(07):18-22